In re Estate of Wilson, 252 S.W.3d 708 (Tex. App.-Texarkana 2008, no pet.h.).WILLS — Lost WillAfter Husband died, Wife was successful in probating Husband’s will eventhough she could not locate the original will. Son (Wife’s step-son)contested the probate of the will claiming that the evidence was legallyinsufficient to rebut the presumption of revocation that arises when theoriginal will cannot be located.The appellate court agreed with Son. The court began its analysis byrecognizing that when a will was last known to be in the testator’spossession and cannot be located after death, a presumption of revocationarises which can be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence. The courtalso explained that “the testator’s continued affection for the chiefbeneficiary [of the will], without evidence tending to show the decedent’sdissatisfaction with the will or any desire to cancel or change the will, issufficient to rebut the presumption of revocation of a missing will.”Wilson at 713.The court then examined the record and found it lacking of any directevidence of why the original will could not be located. Wife’s merestatement that as far as she knew and believed, Husband had not revoked thewill is not evidence of the asserted facts. In addition, there was noevidence of Husband’s continued affection for Wife or that Husband hadcontinued to recognize the will’s validity. Accordingly, the court heldthat the evidence was legally insufficient to rebut the revocationpresumption and remanded the case to the trial court.Note: This case also involved several procedural issues such as therequirements of a restricted appeal, when evidence is considered legallyinsufficient, and proper extent of a remedy (render or remand).Moral: Original wills need to be protected so that they are available atthe time of probate and are not inadvertently lost, destroyed, or located bydisgruntled heirs.For summaries of other recent Texas cases, please follow this link:http://www.professorbeyer.com/Case_Summaries/Texas_Case_Summaries.htm.Posted with permission of the author:Gerry W. BeyerGovernor Preston E. Smith Regents Professor of LawTexas Tech University School of Law
If you would like to discuss this with our firm, please call us at (214) 696-0021, or click below to instant chat with us.
Or click here for Instant Messaging with our office (office hours only)
Post Footer automatically generated by Add Post Footer Plugin for wordpress.
